How to Turn Website Visitors Into Paying Clients (Even If They Aren’t Ready Yet)

Kate shows how to build an email list in Flodesk to turn website visitors into paying clients

Here’s something that took me a while to accept: most of the people who visit your website aren’t ready to hire you today. That’s exactly why your website needs an email list.

They’re researching. They’re comparing options. Maybe they’re planning family photos for next fall, or they know they’ll need a bookkeeper once the business grows a little more. They like what they see, they close the tab, and then life happens.

That doesn’t mean they’re a lost cause. Some of my favorite clients found me months, even years, before they booked. The difference is that I had a way to stay in touch with them in the meantime: an email list.

I’m Kate, founder of Dear Kate Brand Strategy. In this post, I’ll show you the simple setup I use to turn website visitors into email subscribers, and eventually into paying clients, using Flodesk and a Showit website. No complicated funnel required.


Prefer to Watch Instead of Read?

In the full walkthrough video, I set the whole thing up from scratch in a brand-new Flodesk account:


Why Your Website Needs an Email List

Your website does a lot of heavy lifting. It explains what you do, shows people why you’re the right fit, and makes it easy to book. But it can’t follow up.

When someone lands on your site and isn’t ready yet, you have one shot to give them a reason to stay connected. If you don’t, you’re counting on them to remember your name and come back on their own months later. Some will. Most won’t, not because they didn’t like you, but because they’re human.

An email list fixes that. Once someone signs up, you can reach out when you have something they’d want: open dates, a seasonal offer, a new service, or even just a note to say hello. And when they’re finally ready to book, you’re the first person they think of, because you’ve been showing up in their inbox all along.

You Don’t Need a Fancy Freebie

This is where a lot of business owners get stuck. They think they need to create a big, beautiful lead magnet before they can start an email list, so they never start.

You don’t have to make something new. You don’t even have to make something at all. A few ideas that work just as well:

  • Something you already have. My DIY Website Planner started as part of a paid product. I offer it as a free sample, so I didn’t have to build anything extra.
  • A discount or coupon code for a first session or service.
  • A booking bonus, like an extra add-on for anyone who books from your list.
  • A waitlist for something new you’re launching or for dates that sell out.

The goal is simply to give people something valuable enough to say yes, so you can stay in touch until they’re ready.

The Simple System: Four Steps

Here’s the whole setup at a glance:

  1. Create a signup form in Flodesk.
  2. Add the form to your website in Showit.
  3. Write a welcome email that delivers what you promised.
  4. Automate it with a workflow so it sends on its own.

Let’s walk through each one.

Step 1: Create Your Email List Signup Form in Flodesk

Before anything else, set up your brand settings in Flodesk: your fonts, colors, and a little info about your business. It takes a few minutes, and it pays off later, because the AI email tools use those settings to match your brand and voice. (I even uploaded the handwriting font I made for my brand.)

Then create a form. Flodesk gives you a few styles to choose from:

  • Inline (ribbon banner): sits right on a page of your website. This is the one I use most, usually on its own opt-in page.
  • Pop-up: appears over your Showit site.
  • Full page: a separate signup page with its own link.

A few settings I always adjust:

  • Save signups to a segment named after the freebie. A segment is just a group of people. Naming it after the freebie (like “DIY Website Planner opt-in”) makes it easy to tell where everyone came from. You can use segments for other groups too, like past clients or people who booked in a certain year.
  • Make it look like part of your site. Set the form’s canvas and background colors to transparent, then match the button to your brand colors, corner style, and fonts. Your brand fonts show up at the top of the font list.
  • Send people to a thank-you page on your website. Instead of Flodesk’s built-in thank-you message, redirect to a page on your own site. It keeps people on your website longer, which helps your SEO, and gives you a place to point them to a next step.
  • Decide on double opt-in. Double opt-in means people confirm their email before they get the freebie. I usually leave it off.
  • Name your forms clearly and use folders. If you end up with lots of ribbon banner forms like I do, clear names save you later. Each form also shows how many people saw it, how many signed up, and the conversion rate.

When you’re done, click to embed. You’ll need two pieces of code: the header code and the inline code.

Step 2: Add the Form to Your Showit Site

  1. Add the inline code where you want the form. Drop an embed code element onto the page and paste in Flodesk’s inline code. It won’t show up yet, because the header code isn’t installed.
  2. Add the header code site-wide. In Showit, go to Site Settings → Integrations → Add Custom Code → HTML to Head, and paste in Flodesk’s header code.
  3. Attach it to your site canvas sets. Showit loads this head code through your site canvas sets, so apply it to the sets used on every page (or only certain pages, if you’d rather).
  4. Preview and adjust. You may need to go back into Flodesk and tweak the form styling so it fits the page. I changed my field style to solid, rounded the corners to match my buttons, and set the border to my brand color.

Quick tip: if a page doesn’t have a canvas set (like an opt-in page with no menu), create a one-pixel transparent canvas set and add it to the top of the page. Your code will load everywhere without changing how the page looks. I walk through the same trick in my post on installing your Meta Pixel on Showit.

And yes, you could tweak your form’s look forever. Get it close, then move on.

Step 3: Write Your Welcome Email With Flodesk AI

Now that people can sign up, you need to deliver what you promised. Flodesk’s new AI email builder makes this a lot faster.

One thing I learned while testing: start from Emails → New Email, not from inside a workflow. The workflow version doesn’t have the same design features.

Here’s roughly what I typed in:

“I need an email to deliver my free DIY Website Planner. This is going to people who have already opted in to receive it. We need to get them excited about it and click to download their freebie. I want this to have a little bit of an editorial feel with a fun, crafty edge.”

Then I pasted in the copy from my opt-in page so it understood what the planner actually is.

Flodesk wrote the email and designed it, using the fonts, colors, and voice from my brand settings. It gave me a few options to choose from, and then I could ask for changes in plain English. I moved the photo up into the header, above the button, and asked it to trim the middle section.

That second edit matters. Someone who just signed up wants their freebie. Keep the welcome email short and make the download button easy to find.

Step 4: Automate Delivery With a Workflow

Last step: make sure the email goes out on its own.

  1. In Flodesk, go to Workflows → New Workflow. You can start from a template or from scratch.
  2. Choose a trigger. The trigger is what puts someone into the workflow. Here, it’s signing up through your form.
  3. Add a step to send an email. Choose to duplicate an existing email, then pick the welcome email you just made.
  4. Check the subject line and preview text. Flodesk’s AI will suggest a subject line. The preview text is what shows up next to it in the inbox.
  5. Publish.

Now anyone who signs up gets their freebie right away, without you lifting a finger.

If you want to go a step further, workflows can do more than send one email. You can add delays, move people into or out of segments, and add yes/no branches. For example, if someone didn’t open or click to download the planner, you could send them a friendly reminder. Those little branches make your emails feel more personal.

What Happens Next: Stay in Touch With Your Email List

Getting people on your email list is the start, not the finish. From here, keep showing up in their inbox so they remember you exist. When they’re ready to book, you want to be the obvious first call because you’ve already built that connection.

Here’s what that looks like in real life. My photography business is on the back burner these days. I don’t send regular emails for it. But the opt-in forms are still running, and my website still brings in new people.

This fall, I sent one email about mini sessions:

  • It went to 378 people.
  • 109 opened it, a 28.8% open rate, which is on the low side because I haven’t been nurturing that list.
  • It got 16 clicks.
  • And it filled all 9 of my mini session spots.

Mini sessions only go out to my email list now, and I fill them every time. The people who found my photography website months or years ago weren’t going to remember to check back for mini session dates. But because they’re on my list, I can reach out whenever I have something they’d want.

You don’t need thousands of subscribers or a complicated funnel for this to work. Get people on your email list, give them something valuable, and you’ll have a way to reach out when they’re ready.

A Quick Note on Flodesk Pricing

I’m a Flodesk partner, and one of the reasons I recommend it is that it’s brought back unlimited pricing. You pay one flat rate no matter how many subscribers, emails, workflows, or forms you have, so growing your list doesn’t grow your bill.

At the time of writing (November 2026):

  • Unlimited Email: $46/month or $456/year
  • Unlimited Everything: $99/month or $948/year, which adds checkout features like buy now, pay later, subscriptions, and payment plans

Pricing can change, so check Flodesk’s site for current plans and trial details.

Try Flodesk


Not Sure What to Offer?

If you’re stuck on what to give people in exchange for their email, leave a comment on the video telling me what you do, and I’ll help you brainstorm something simple. Remember, it doesn’t have to be big. It just has to be worth saying yes to.

Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means I may receive a small commission if you make a purchase through one of these links, at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products and services I personally use, trust, and genuinely believe will benefit my audience. Thank you for supporting my work and helping me continue to provide helpful, free content.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My first business was behind the camera, and thanks to the right website and systems, it now runs mostly in the background — bringing in clients while I focus on helping solopreneurs like you build brands that book.

Whether I’m behind the lens or behind a screen, I’m all about finding simpler, smarter ways to grow a sustainable business — with clear messaging, clean design, solid boundaries, and a little help from AI.

Because between carpools, practice runs, and Knowledge Bowl meets, I need a business that works even when I’m not.

Grab my free website training to learn how to make your site your hardest-working team member.
Yes! I Want a Website That Works

Hi, I’m Kate — brand strategist, web designer, and yes, still a working photographer.

Yes! I Want in!